Learn All You Need to Know
Are you thinking about a new furnace but feel lost comparing oil vs. gas furnaces? This guide simplifies things, giving you the information to make a confident choice for your home. So, if you’re shivering at the thought of another winter with an unreliable heating system, start by comparing oil vs. gas furnaces.
For over a decade, I’ve worked with homeowners just like you grappling with this decision. It’s a big one. Your furnace affects not only warmth but also your budget and the planet. This isn’t just a technical comparison; it’s about making the smart pick to stay comfortable for years to come.
Comparing Oil vs. Gas Furnaces: Fuel and Efficiency
Natural gas furnaces are popular, heating about 50% of US homes. They connect directly to a supply line, ensuring constant fuel and taking the burden of fuel level monitoring off of you. Oil furnaces, however, need fuel oil deliveries to an on-site storage tank, and you manage the supply yourself.
Efficiency-wise, look at the Annual Fuel Utilization Efficiency (AFUE) rating. A higher AFUE rating means better fuel utilization efficiency and less fuel waste. Gas furnaces typically score between 89%–98% AFUE, edging out oil’s 80%–90%.
Though, renewable biofuels offer a cleaner oil option, which can reduce environmental impact. When considering fuel sources for heating, it is good to know which is higher energy: gas or oil? While both have their own pros and cons, understanding higher energy and AFUE ratings helps narrow your selection down. While you can find higher AFUE ratings with gas, oil tends to generate more heat per BTU than natural gas. This means it can heat a space more quickly, although with lower overall efficiency in the long run. This makes gas furnaces ideal for individuals living in densely populated areas where air quality and methane emissions are concerns.
Comparing Oil vs. Gas Furnaces: Cost Considerations
Think short-term and long-term costs. Oil furnaces typically have lower initial purchase prices but potentially higher fuel expenses and upkeep compared to gas furnace systems. Because fuel oil prices can fluctuate, your heating costs can swing too.
Gas furnaces cost a bit more upfront, but they typically offer more consistent long-term value and tend to cost less over time. They run more efficiently and draw on a stable, locally sourced natural gas supply.
I’ve seen firsthand how unpredictable fuel costs can disrupt household budgets, so consistent pricing is definitely attractive. This may make a difference, as natural gas furnaces might edge out oil furnaces for their lower operational expenses.
Comparing Oil vs. Gas Furnaces: Safety
Both oil and natural gas furnaces come with safety concerns and must be professionally installed. One of the dangers of burning fuel is the possibility of carbon monoxide poisoning, making annual maintenance and inspections even more vital. This risk exists for both gas and oil furnaces.
Gas leaks present a higher risk of fire and explosion, and natural gas furnaces require careful venting to prevent carbon monoxide buildup. Oil furnaces also need proper ventilation to prevent soot buildup and ensure safe operation. However, since fuel oil isn’t as flammable as natural gas, oil furnace leaks do not carry as high a fire risk. This can contribute to some peace of mind when deciding between the two different furnace systems. An additional benefit of having heating oil as your fuel type is the reduced environmental impact with the reduction of methane emissions. Another important thing to look out for are additional local and federal government regulations around your specific home.
Comparing Oil vs. Gas Furnaces: Environmental Impact
While gas burns cleaner than oil, both produce emissions. Oil systems may require more frequent cleanings to clear soot, adding to maintenance. Newer models do offer reduced emissions compared to traditional oil heating.
Both oil and natural gas are fossil fuels, contributing to climate change. However, natural gas generally produces fewer emissions than oil when burned. While oil furnaces don’t require a local utility company connection, their combustion can produce air pollutants. Natural gas furnaces also don’t have to deal with handling and storing oil.
Comparing Oil vs. Gas Furnaces: Maintenance
With oil furnaces, be ready for more regular maintenance than with natural gas furnaces. You’ll likely need annual inspections, filter replacements, and periodic cleaning.
These maintenance needs are partly because fuel oil tends to create more buildup from burning. Gas furnaces require maintenance as well, such as inspections and filter changes, but these are typically less frequent than oil furnaces.
A gas furnace connects directly to a local utility company supply line. With an oil furnace, the homeowner must arrange for oil deliveries. Since local utility company maintenance services aren’t always an option, this can add another item to the to-do list for homeowners.
FAQs about Comparing Oil vs. Gas Furnaces
Which is better, a gas or oil furnace?
The “better” choice depends on individual circumstances. Factors to consider include your budget, the availability of natural gas in your area, your environmental concerns, and your comfort level with maintenance. Gas tends to be preferred for affordability and convenience.
While gas furnaces burn more efficiently and emit fewer emissions, gas itself is less environmentally sound than oil. Natural gas is also generally easier to maintain and manage, offering an uninterrupted supply through the utility company’s infrastructure. Meanwhile, an oil furnace provides more control over the supply, as you purchase oil yourself and arrange its delivery.
What is the disadvantage of an oil furnace?
Oil furnaces have a few drawbacks. The fluctuating price of oil can lead to unpredictable heating costs, requiring more extensive maintenance to prevent excessive emissions. You’ll also deal with annual fuel deliveries and the storage of oil tanks.
There’s also the possibility of higher upfront costs if your home isn’t equipped for oil heat. Depending on your location, you might also need to monitor fuel levels yourself. This adds extra work and responsibility, especially for busy homeowners with limited time.
Is it cheaper to heat your house with gas or oil?
Generally, natural gas is cheaper for home heating in the long term. However, current prices and appliance efficiency vary by region, vendor, and usage.
Natural gas prices tend to be more stable, while fuel oil is prone to significant price swings. Fuel oil burns hotter, meaning quick heating albeit with less efficiency. When comparing the different aspects between gas heating and oil heating, it’s also worth taking into consideration carbon monoxide poisoning that can arise from any combustion of fuels and what local or national policies you may want to keep in mind to stay up to date.
Is it worth changing from oil to gas heat?
Switching from oil to natural gas can be pricey, involving pipeline hookups and the removal of the old system. This makes the change unattractive to some homeowners.
While worthwhile long-term if natural gas is readily available, carefully weigh costs against projected savings with the switch. Keep in mind local utility company requirements, to help ensure your system functions as intended with these sources.
Conclusion
Comparing oil vs. gas furnaces is more than comparing BTUs and efficiency ratings; it’s about balancing your present needs with your future goals. From upfront costs and energy bills to environmental concerns such as reducing methane emissions, the right decision will bring comfort to both your home and your bank account.
Contact us today for more information or to schedule a free consultation.
